Why Your Operating Agreement Is Not Enough

The document every family business has — and why it will not save you

You formed an LLC for your family business. Your attorney filed the paperwork with the Secretary of State and handed you an operating agreement. You signed it, filed it away, and assumed you were protected.

You are not.

The standard operating agreement addresses what the law requires. It names the members. It allocates ownership percentages. It may include some basic provisions about voting and distributions. What it almost never addresses is what will actually tear your family apart.

What the Standard Agreement Misses

I have reviewed hundreds of operating agreements for family businesses. Most of them are functionally useless when conflict arrives. They answer the legal questions and ignore the human ones.

They do not address who makes day-to-day decisions versus strategic decisions. They do not establish how a family member gets removed from management if they are not performing. They do not specify what happens when one member wants to sell and another does not. They do not contemplate divorce — and what happens when your brother's ex-wife suddenly owns part of your family business.

They do not address compensation for family members who work in the business versus those who do not. They do not establish how disputes get resolved before they become lawsuits. They do not plan for the founder's death, disability, or retirement in any meaningful way.

In other words, they do not address any of the things that actually cause family businesses to implode.

The Myth of Equal Ownership

Many family business operating agreements split ownership equally among the children. Mom and Dad had three kids, so each child gets one-third. Fair, right?

Not when one child runs the business sixty hours a week while another lives in another state and checks in at Christmas. Not when one child took a below-market salary for years to keep the business afloat while another drew the same distributions without any sacrifice. Not when one child's spouse is actively involved while another's spouse is hostile to the whole enterprise.

Equal ownership does not mean equal contribution, equal commitment, or equal sacrifice. And when that inequality finally surfaces and it to often does, the operating agreement offers no guidance.

What a Family Business Actually Needs

A family business needs governance documents that reflect how families actually function, not how corporations function. This means:

Decision-making frameworks that distinguish between operational decisions, financial decisions, and strategic decisions and specify who has authority over each.

Employment versus ownership separation. You can own part of a business without working in it, and you can work in a business without owning it. The operating agreement should address compensation, roles, and expectations for each category.

Exit mechanisms. What happens when someone wants out? What happens when someone needs to be removed? What happens in death, disability, or divorce? These provisions should be detailed and specific, not afterthoughts.

Dispute resolution. A requirement to mediate before litigating can save a family. So can regular family meetings with structured agendas. So can bringing in outside advisors before positions harden.

Succession planning. Not vague intentions, but actual timelines, milestones, and transition plans.

The Time to Plan Is Now

The operating agreement sitting in your filing cabinet was probably drafted when everyone was optimistic and getting along. That is exactly when governance documents should be created and exactly when most families skip the hard conversations.

If your family business is operating under a standard form operating agreement, you are not protected. You have a document that will tell a court how to divide the pieces after everything is broken. What you need is a document that keeps everything from breaking in the first place.

That requires a different kind of planning and a different kind of conversation.

___

Kim Haney is an attorney licensed in Mississippi, Alabama, and Alaska, with nearly thirty years of experience in family law and business planning. Her practice focuses on planning, mediation, and education — helping clients build structures that prevent conflict rather than litigate it. She can be reached at Kim@KimHaneyLawOffice.com.